Project

General

Profile

VibrantIndexInterface » History » Version 8

Lorna Morris, 05/31/2012 05:53 PM

1 1 Lorna Morris
2 2 Lorna Morris
# Skype Meeting, ViBRANT Index Issues, (Anton, Andreas M., Andreas K., Lorna)  31.5.2012
3 1 Lorna Morris
4 1 Lorna Morris
5 1 Lorna Morris
6 4 Lorna Morris
7 1 Lorna Morris
## How do we display links for Misapplied names in the VIBRANT search index?
8 1 Lorna Morris
9 1 Lorna Morris
10 7 Lorna Morris
* A distinct name can have more than one status (e.g. Misapplied name, Accepted Taxon) in a single multi-classification source. Currently the VIBRANT index doesn't indicate which Taxa the name is misapplied for. Thus status should be applied to a Taxon Relationship rather than the Taxon itself.
11 1 Lorna Morris
12 1 Lorna Morris
13 7 Lorna Morris
* Longer-term solution: Discuss re-modelling the CDM. Misapplied name is the status of a Taxon Relationship not a Taxon. Misapplied names are currently handled the same as Accepted Taxa in the CDM. They should be handled differently. Changing the model will impact the taxonomic Editor and other software. Updating the model may be useful for the Redlist project.
14 1 Lorna Morris
15 1 Lorna Morris
16 7 Lorna Morris
* Shorter-term-solution: Change the interface to direct the user to the available information. If we have a Taxon without a classification id then we could report the source as 'Misapplied name'.However there could be several reasons why the Taxon is not attached to a classification so 'Other status' may be more appropriate. Another solution is to show concept relationships in the interface, therefore even is we keep status 'Accepted' for Misapplied names it makes the status clearer (see below).
17 1 Lorna Morris
18 1 Lorna Morris
19 1 Lorna Morris
20 5 Lorna Morris
21 1 Lorna Morris
## Should we show Concept Relationships in the user interface?
22 5 Lorna Morris
23 1 Lorna Morris
24 1 Lorna Morris
25 1 Lorna Morris
* IOPI shows Concept Relationships (Misapplied Names are shown as Accepted for a given Concept).
26 1 Lorna Morris
27 1 Lorna Morris
28 8 Lorna Morris
* The service method we use to extract the data from the CDM returns all Taxon relationships for a given Taxon, therefore we could display this information in the user interface.
29 1 Lorna Morris
30 8 Lorna Morris
 Solution: Display multiple URLs  (e.g. to the "Accepted Taxa" of a Misapplied Name) for cases where the Taxon has multiple 
31 1 Lorna Morris
32 1 Lorna Morris
33 1 Lorna Morris
Concept relationships.
34 1 Lorna Morris
35 1 Lorna Morris
36 1 Lorna Morris
37 6 Lorna Morris
38 1 Lorna Morris
## What is meant by Source and what should we display in the Interface
39 1 Lorna Morris
40 1 Lorna Morris
41 1 Lorna Morris
* Currently the VIBRANT index interface shows the sec reference as source. We agree that the sec reference should always be 
42 1 Lorna Morris
43 1 Lorna Morris
44 1 Lorna Morris
displayed (and labeled such). A Taxon concept can have multiple sources. Currently in the CDM a Taxon name can have set of 
45 1 Lorna Morris
46 1 Lorna Morris
47 1 Lorna Morris
sources. For the index we want to display the last source in our interface but distinguishing the last source in the CDM is 
48 1 Lorna Morris
49 1 Lorna Morris
50 1 Lorna Morris
currently not possible.
51 1 Lorna Morris
52 1 Lorna Morris
53 1 Lorna Morris
* Short-term solution: The import gives a title for the source e.g. Euro+Med (for the current data remove all sources but the 
54 1 Lorna Morris
55 1 Lorna Morris
56 1 Lorna Morris
last and show it)
57 1 Lorna Morris
58 1 Lorna Morris
59 1 Lorna Morris
* Longer-term solution: Re-model the CDM. Change the set of sources to a sequence of sources. The problem is that we don't 
60 1 Lorna Morris
61 1 Lorna Morris
62 1 Lorna Morris
always have this information. And further complexity can arise when 2 sources are merged. A simplier solution is to just add 
63 1 Lorna Morris
64 1 Lorna Morris
65 1 Lorna Morris
a flag 'last source' when we don't know the sequence.
66 1 Lorna Morris
67 1 Lorna Morris
68 1 Lorna Morris
69 1 Lorna Morris
70 1 Lorna Morris
## What should we display in the the link to each source
71 1 Lorna Morris
72 1 Lorna Morris
73 1 Lorna Morris
* Andreas K suggests we map URL's to human readable strings. URL's don't always have a human readable component so we cna't 
74 1 Lorna Morris
75 1 Lorna Morris
76 1 Lorna Morris
always parse this, but sources do ahve a title so we can display this for the link. In most cases there is only one source. 
77 1 Lorna Morris
78 1 Lorna Morris
79 1 Lorna Morris
In cases where there are multiple sources we should show a list of links to sources (labelled as either 'Source history' or 
80 1 Lorna Morris
81 1 Lorna Morris
82 1 Lorna Morris
'Contributing Sources'). 
83 1 Lorna Morris
84 1 Lorna Morris
85 1 Lorna Morris
* Longer-term solution: Re-model the CDM. Currently the URL is added to the Taxon. We should add the URL to the Source.
86 1 Lorna Morris
87 1 Lorna Morris
88 1 Lorna Morris
89 1 Lorna Morris
90 1 Lorna Morris
## What should we display for Status
91 1 Lorna Morris
92 1 Lorna Morris
93 1 Lorna Morris
* Currently we are using Taxon, Synonym for the status (the class name from the CDM). Should Taxon be chnaged to 'Accepted 
94 1 Lorna Morris
95 1 Lorna Morris
96 1 Lorna Morris
Taxon'. We've decided to use "Accepted" as in PESI. In the cases where the name is Accepted and Misapplied in a single 
97 1 Lorna Morris
98 1 Lorna Morris
99 1 Lorna Morris
source, we will also provide this information as described above.
Add picture from clipboard (Maximum size: 40 MB)