task #7918
closedRevision of reference type specific properties
100%
Description
Reference Editor of Vaadin (2018-11-02) in square brackets: Differences in the TaxEditor
Article
Date published: ok
Title: ok [TaxEditor: also a nomencl. Title is given, in a few cases in TL2 there is an abbreviated title is given]
Authors: ok
In-reference: ok
Series: not sure if needed. Is there a use case? [TaxEditor: also available, ask other projects if needed]
Volume: ok
Uri: ok
MISSING IN VAADIN: DOI [also missing in TaxEditor, this seems to be an issue]
Journal
Date published: needed for the runtime of a journal? E.g. 1945-1990??
Title: ok
Nomenclatural title: ok
Authors: NOT NEEDED [also available in TaxEditor]
In-reference: NOT NEEDED [not in TaxEditor]
Place published: ok (but changes often in the runtime)
Publisher: ok (but changes often in the runtime)
ISSN: ok (nice to have: two fields for print and e-journal, respective)
DOI: In VAADIN NOT NEEDED [not in TaxEditor]
Uri: ok
Book section (Layout in Vaadin narrow)
Date published: just needed, if parts of a book are printed independently
MISSING: Title [available in TaxEditor]
Authors: ok
In-reference: ok
Pages: ok
URI: ok
MISSING: DOI [also missing in TaxEditor, this seems to be an issue]
Book
Date published: ok
Title: okay
Nomenclatural title: ok
Authors: ok
In-reference: ok [in TaxEditor “In Series”]
Series: (Discuss: isn’t In-reference the right place to store and select a series, rather than in a string?) [also available in TaxEditor]
Volume: ok
Pages: ok
Edition: ok
Place published: ok
Publisher: ok
Editor: ok (discuss: person/team atomized?) [same in TaxEditor]
ISBN: ok (nice to have: two fields for print and e-journal, respective)
DOI: ok [MISSING in TaxEditor, this might be an issue in future]
Uri: ok
Inproceedings (might be renamed as Proceedings section)
Date published: just needed, if parts of a book are printed independently
Title: ok
Authors: ok
In-reference: ok
Series: NOT NEEDED [also available in TaxEditor ]
Pages: ok
DOI: ok
URI: ok [MISSING in TaxEditor, this might be an issue in future]
Proceedings
See Book, except for “Edition” but two editions of proceedings cannot be excluded…
ISBN: [MISSING in TaxEditor]
Printseries
Date published: needed for the runtime of a print series? E.g. 1945-1990??
Title: ok
MISSING: Nomenclatural title
Authors: needed? Maybe in a special case
In-reference: Maybe for a print series within a print series?
MISSING Edition: Discuss: this might be useful, if there are editions of print series, such as Adolf Engler’s Syllabus, do not know if we really need this.
Place published: ok
Publisher: ok
Editor: ok (discuss: person/team atomized?)
ISBN: ok (nice to have: two fields for print and e-journal, respective) [MISSING in TaxEditor]
DOI: NEEDED? [not in TaxEditor]
Uri: ok (but changes often in the runtime)
Thesis
Okay, except of MISSING: School [see TaxEditor]
Discuss: A thesis is an effectively published book (see book) or a not effectively published book, an Internet resource, or a microfiche. How to deal with this? Should the Reference type called “Thesis (not effectively published)? If not, we need a “not published” flag, if applicable a text field for the reason. The thing is, that any thesis has a date, a place, sometimes a publisher, even it is not published effectively. This is important, because a lot of novelties have been printed in not effectively published theses. Alternatively we could leave “Thesis” as is, and flag each nomenclatural act as invalid with reference to the respective provisions of the ICN, that this was not effectively published. In Vaadin “School” might be stored under Publisher.
Related issues