bug #7388
inconsistent handling of null values passed to addNameRelation methods in TaxonName
Start date:
04/28/2018
Due date:
% Done:
0%
Severity:
normal
Found in Version:
Description
addBasionym() ignores retuns null and addRelationshipToName() throws an exception
@Override
public NameRelationship addBasionym(TaxonName basionym, Reference citation, String microcitation, String ruleConsidered){
if (basionym != null){
return basionym.addRelationshipToName(this, NameRelationshipType.BASIONYM(), citation, microcitation, ruleConsidered);
}else{
return null;
}
}
public NameRelationship addRelationshipToName(TaxonName toName, NameRelationshipType type, Reference citation, String microCitation, String ruleConsidered){
if (toName == null){
throw new NullPointerException("Null is not allowed as name for a name relationship");
}
NameRelationship rel = new NameRelationship(toName, this, type, citation, microCitation, ruleConsidered);
return rel;
}
I think addBasionym() should behave the same as addRelationshipToName() and should throw an exception.
Associated revisions
ref #7386 reducing redundancy in name relationship handling methods, adding methods for general use
ref #7386 fix error in new getRelatedNames method
ref #7388 fix error in new removeRelationWithTaxonName
History
#1 Updated by Andreas Kohlbecker over 2 years ago
- Subject changed from inconsistent handling of null valued passed to addNameRelatinon methods in TaxonName to inconsistent handling of null values passed to addNameRelation methods in TaxonName
#2 Updated by Andreas Kohlbecker over 2 years ago
The addReplacedSynonym() again follows a completely different philosophy:
//TODO: Check if true: The replaced synonym cannot have itself a replaced synonym (?).
@Override
public void addReplacedSynonym(TaxonName replacedSynonym, Reference citation, String microcitation, String ruleConsidered){
if (replacedSynonym != null){
replacedSynonym.addRelationshipToName(this, NameRelationshipType.REPLACED_SYNONYM(), citation, microcitation, ruleConsidered);
}
}
#3 Updated by Andreas Kohlbecker over 2 years ago
refactoring of other name relationship related methods in 7a72a0fe
