feature request #3337
open
Correct multiple occurrences of basionym within a homotypic group
Added by Cherian Mathew about 11 years ago.
Updated about 7 years ago.
Description
From Eckhard,
"
Per definition, a homotypic group can only have one basionym. So, when a basionym has been chosen for a homotypic group with the Editor (right mouse click), this option should not be available any more for the other members of the same homotypic group. Currently, I can chose all the names within a homotypic group as basionyms, and all the relations between names will be created! This should not be allowed! (a warning might pop up saying "this homotypic group already has a basionym. Do you want to replace this with the new one now"?)
"
From Andreas,
"
generally the Editor philosophie is to have as little warnings which need user interaction as possible, so instead of having an extra warning we could I would prefer to simply change the right click menu label to a label which fully expresses what happens if you push the menu item (e.g. something like "make this name the only basionym of the group" but a bit shorter).
A question about Eckhard statement that there is always just 1 basionym per group: I remember 2 names/taxa in E+M having 2 basionyms, which is a rare exception but an exception that exists. As it is a rare exception we can handle it via the details view rather than the freetext editing. However, also for dirty data (which I regularly work with) it is important that the Editor is still able to show the fact that there is more than 1 basionym for a given homotypic group, even if the freetext area does not allow to create this kind of data. This is important because otherwise the fact is unvisible to the taxonomist who wants to clean up the data.
Who ever is going to implement this, please have this in mind.
"
- Target version deleted ()
- Assignee changed from Andreas Müller to c.mathew -
- Category changed from architecture to taxeditor
- Target version deleted (
TaxEditor RELEASE 3.3.0)
- Target version deleted ()
no release 3.3.1 of the taxeditor so I am moving all tickets to the next milestone 3.3.2
- Target version deleted (
TaxEditor RELEASE 3.4.0)
Moving tickets to 3.4.1 milestone
- Target version deleted ()
Moving tickets that were auto assigned to me to the unassigned milestone
- Assignee changed from c.mathew - to Andreas Müller
define as validation rule
- Subject changed from Correct multiple occurrences of basionym within a homtypic group to Correct multiple occurrences of basionym within a homotypic group
- Description updated (diff)
- Private changed from Yes to No
Also available in: Atom
PDF